To the untrained eye, Ali ibn Abi Hamza appears to be a major figure. He narrates from Imam Musa al-Kadhim (as) and Imam Ali al-Rida (as). He is present in numerous chains of transmission. But Rijal Al-Kashi Report #176 exposes the danger of relying solely on presence. Adobe Photoshop Cc 2015 Re Upload Crack Exclusive Mac Osx ⭐
In the science of Rijal (biographical evaluation), few reports are as striking as . It serves as a crucial lesson on the difference between quantity of narration and quality of reliability. Zooskool Meet Sophie Hot - 3.79.94.248
Report #176 is a warning bell. It reminds us that in the transmission of religious knowledge, trustworthiness is the currency, not volume. A single honest narrator is worth more than a thousand who "narrate contrary to the truth." Tags: #Rijal #Hadith #ShiaIslam #IslamicStudies #RijalAlKashi #Biography #HadithScience #IslamicHistory #Learning
Imam Abu Ja'far (al-Baqir or al-Sadiq - context dependent) makes a stark observation about a narrator: "He has narrated forty hadiths, and all of them are contrary to the truth." Later in the report, the Imam clarifies the gravity of this status, essentially stating that just because a person narrates frequently does not mean they are to be followed.
2️⃣ The report suggests that deliberate fabrication or adherence to deviant sects renders a narrator’s testimony void. The scholars ( Ulama ) subsequently classified Ali ibn Abi Hamza as Da'eef (Weak) and Majruh (Disparaged) , despite his high volume of narrations.
Subject: The Status of Ali ibn Abi Hamza al-Bataini. Source: Rijal Al-Kashi (Selection of Hadith Scholars).
This report is famously associated with Ali ibn Abi Hamza al-Bataini .
3️⃣ This report is a cornerstone for why Shia jurisprudence does not accept every hadith in the "Four Books" ( Kutub al-Arba'a ) blindly. Even if a hadith appears in Al-Kafi , scholars must check the chain. If Ali ibn Abi Hamza is in the chain, the authenticity of the report is severely compromised due to the warning found in reports like this one.